Outlook on mortgage interest rates

By Paul Ho

/ iCompareLoan.com, The Edge Property |

August 11, 2015 9:00 AM SGT

To go into the topic of where mortgage interest rates in Singapore are headed, it is important to review the root cause. Analyst and economist have lamented for years that printing money (also known as Quantitative easing QE) leads to low interest rate and that in turn leads to high inflation. They have been wrong for seven years in a row. Many newspapers that give headlines after headlines of sensational news of low interest rates leads to inflation have fallen flat for seven years in a row.

If you look at the chart of US Inflation rate versus US Fed funds rate, you will see that low interest rates since 2008 till now in 2015 have not led to inflation. In fact, inflation has dropped to almost zero. Therefore low interest rates do not necessarily lead to inflation, it depends on context.

In the case of Singapore, apart from the recent spike in January 2015, the low interest rates persisted since 2009 and inflation spiked at about 3.5% and then drop to almost 0 recently. And instead of rising inflation rate, inflation was in fact falling.

For a country with a large domestic economy, one of the key leading indicators for inflation is unemployment rate and disposable income growth. A low unemployment rate usually leads to strong income growth and hence inflation. Hence it is income growth that eventually leads to inflation.

The US unemployment rate is now 5.3% (Part of US full employment figures could potentially be skewed by election spending in the USA).

The past economic booms corresponds to unemployment rates of around 4 to 4.5%. Hence the US is approaching “full employment”. However income growth has been soft, coupled by softer crude oil prices, inflation remains soft.

The US Fed adopts a policy stance of Maximum employment and medium range inflation target of 2%.

Weak global growth is evident when China further reduced its interest rates to 4.85% to stimulate growth. So the real issue is really one of deflation or low inflation, not inflation.

Why are we talking about other countries when we talk about Singapore mortgage interest rate trends?

The Singapore Sibor overnight rate closely corresponds to the US Fed funds rate. An increase in the Fed overnight funds rate will likely be follow suit by Singapore.

The Fed’s unemployment figures for 2015 is achieved. Their view is balanced between generating further employment and maintaining inflation.

Chart 1

Source: Trading economics

Chart 2

Source: Trading economics, iCompareloan.com

Exchange Rates Movement

Singapore is a small economy with a large external trade, so it makes sense to control exchange rates against its major trading partners to moderate imported inflation.

SGD is weakening against the USD

SGD is strengthening against the EURO

SGD is strengthening against the YEN

Volatile exchange rates often leads to loss of confidence and leads to exodus of funds.

If you are a hedge fund manager holding a currency that is expected to weaken 5% in a year, while only earning 1% deposit interest rate, would you be tempted to switch out of this currency? Would you be less likely to move your money if interest rates are higher?

The Fed is likely to raise interest rates in 2H2015. Therefore smart money has already moved into the USD in anticipation of both the US economic recovery as well as the better yield (deposit rates). In order to prevent exodus of funds to the US market, Singapore’s regulators may have to act pre-emptively themselves or via proxy to raise interest rates. (they have been not known to intervene in rates, though)

Chart 3

Source: Trading Economics, iCompareLoan.com

Chart 4

Source: ieconomics, iCompareLoan.com

Deposit Rates already higher than Sibor

Several banks are offering fixed deposit rates (24 months) at 1.8 to 1.95% and 10 month fixed deposits at around 1.5% while Sibor (12 month) is only about 1.06%.

There is a discrepancy in rates between Sibor (12 month) and Fixed Deposit rates. Even though these are promotional deposit rates, what this means is that the banks see interest rates rising and are starting to lock in deposits in anticipation of rising interest rates.

Chart 5

Source: iCompareLoan.com

Singapore Savings Bond – Singapore Heavily in Debt

The Singapore Savings Bond is schedule for release in 2H, 2015. The initial tranches are for 1 to 2 billion dollars. The offered interest rate is about 2.5% (if held to maturity of 10 years). The amount being raised is still insignificant relative to the overall deposits. Nonetheless it is worrying that Singapore is borrowing so much despite being one of the world’s most indebted nations at Debt to GDP ratio of 382%. A large part of these debt is owed via the CPF. Savings Bond is unlikely to affect Singapore’s interest rates in the short term due to the small tranche. This is nonetheless a worrying trend in the longer term when the tranches gets bigger, sucking up more funds and impacts interest rates.

Summary

There is a benign inflation and moderate growth in Singapore coupled with near “full employment” in the USA at 5.3% while inflation is close to 0% (due in part to low crude oil prices). Global weak growth and a deflationary environment leads many countries such as China to reduce interest rates. The Fed’s policy stance is for “Maximum employment” and 2% inflation target rate, hence it can wait a while before raising rates as long as inflation stays low. At a rate of ~0.1% drop in unemployment a month, by November it should fall below 5% at current trajectory and the Fed may be tempted to raise Fed Funds target rate by 0.25% to 0.5% as a precautionary measure.

Singapore’s interest rates should also start to rise considering the weakening Singapore dollar and correlation to the US Fed Funds rate. Singapore’s deposit rates being higher than Sibor also point to an increasing interest rate environment.

While many factors are at play, we foresee a moderate increase of 0.20% (lower range) to 0.75% (top range) in Sibor rates. One-month Sibor is now at 0.76%, and we estimate that it could end up at between 0.95% and 1.5% at year-end.

This article appeared in The Edge Property Pullout of Issue 689 (August 10) of The Edge Singapore.

Paul Ho is founder of www.iCompareLoan.com. The views expressed here are his own.

Tags: